Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 15 of 20

Thread: Always neck size other rifle's brass?

  1. #1
    Join Date
    Dec 2003
    Location
    Aylesbury
    Posts
    3,412

    Always neck size other rifle's brass?

    Chaps,

    Interesting one here. I've always been told and read that when you're reloading cases that have not been fired in the rifle you're reloading for you must full length size. No qualifications, no "but if they chamber OK you're OK neck sizing only".

    My question is- what am I missing here; the only reason I can think of for full length sizing is to prevent issues with the brass not fitting in the rifle's chamber (for a bolt action for target shooting). I have a quantity of once fired .300 Win Mag brass for my new to me rifle which was not fired in the rifle.

    Happy to full length resize this time if necessary, but prefer neck sizing and trying to work out why I shouldn't.
    Last edited by zanes; 06-05-2016 at 08:58 AM.

  2. #2
    Parabuteo is offline My Chrony has bought it a couple of times...
    Join Date
    Mar 2006
    Location
    Southampton
    Posts
    6,061
    Quote Originally Posted by zanes View Post
    Chaps,

    Interesting one here. I've always been told and read that when you're reloading cases that have not been fired in the rifle you're reloading for you must neck size. No qualifications, no "but if they chamber OK you're OK neck sizing only".

    My question is- what am I missing here; the only reason I can think of for full length sizing is to prevent issues with the brass not fitting in the rifle's chamber (for a bolt action for target shooting). I have a quantity of once fired .300 Win Mag brass for my new to me rifle which was not fired in the rifle.

    Happy to full length resize this time if necessary, but prefer neck sizing and trying to work out why I shouldn't.
    Its an odd one Zanes.

    Some folk I know insist on FL sizing every firing. If you do that with a rifle that has a generous head space, you may well be speeding up the destruction of your brass by work hardening it near the head and stretching and compressing it as the lot moves forwards and stops at the shoulders.

    When I used to FL resize for my .303, the brass would give up after about 3 shots. As soon as I went to neck only (after an initial reset for once fired) they last for 10 or so...I have not had a separation since doing this and the primer pockets tend to give up before the cases do.

    It depends a lot on your rifle, but with once fired brass I would always normalise it and work from there. I recently had a first which was my M67 refusing to chamber some hand loads. I had (without thinking about it) bunged some fresh brass in to top up some lost cases that had been prepped, less FL sizing.

    They had come from a big bag of .308 that had been through any one of 12 AIs, my bad...

    I now have 3 big tubs and when cases come back they get dumped into the "Needs cleaning" tub. When de-capped and cleaned they go into the "Needs sizing tub" where they get that and any trimming that needs doing, then they go to the "loading" tub....all in their respective boxes of course.

    Also, some rifles actually seem to shoot FL resized cases better for each firing. Some will also become un-chamberable after 5 firings or so (A certain to shot told me that he FL resized after 5 firings after not being able to chamber rounds that had been fired in his rifle but just neck sized).

    There is no one size fits all solution mate. My intention is to work the brass and my fingers as little as possible....and keep it consistent.

    Oddly, if I use federal .308 brass (which I have been using as they come free) I need to open the necks with a mandrel after any sizing as they tend to scrape the bullets.
    I'm a maggot in another life you know

  3. #3
    Join Date
    Dec 2003
    Location
    Aylesbury
    Posts
    3,412
    Thanks Parabeuto.

    I've been stung by a similar situation to that you describe when I bought some deprimed (but not sized) 308 brass a while back. Got halfway through FL'ing the batch at the end of a reloading session and then packed up. A few weeks later when priming cases I found that box and, as I always resize when depriming, assumed they'd been sized. It was only when I came to bullet seating I realised why the bullets were a "tad" loose in some of the cases. That taught me a lesson....

    I can certainly see your point about "resetting" the brass to a known state (i.e. FL sizing them this time around).

    In the absence of any definitive reasoning I suppose the thing to do would be a thorough check of chamber fit across the entire batch and go from there. If it's good I think I'll neck size; 300 win mag brass life with FL sizing is not good from what I've read.

  4. #4
    Randy Bohannon's Avatar
    Randy Bohannon is offline “Junes1 is a whining bellend”
    Join Date
    Jan 2007
    Location
    London
    Posts
    28,522
    The answer to this is something called "partial full length neck size", it's easier to google the details than it is for me to repeat them.

    th basic idea is to use the FL die to just kiss the shoulder of the case at the end of the reloading stroke. The headspace is kept fairly tight, only about 0.002" shoulder set back or so that it chambers with barely any resistance, comparable to neck sizing and the case chambers like butter.

    I started doing this after finding that the cases in my 06 were stretching after 5 firing cycles, sized with a lee collet die.

    FL sizing once fired brass is just good practice as far as I'm concerned though, gives a baseline after trimming for sorting.
    "An infinite number of monkeys banging away at type writers for an infinite period of time will eventually reproduce Hamlet" Thanks to discussion forums we now know this to be untrue.

  5. #5
    Join Date
    Apr 2014
    Location
    Watford
    Posts
    927
    I would full length resize , trim to length , then load - fire and then neck size. That way you start at known constant .
    I would only then FL resize when difficult to chamber/or the cases stretch.

    James

  6. #6
    Join Date
    Jan 2008
    Location
    Daventry. Northants.
    Posts
    3,534
    I have never neck or full length sized new brass and never will, i do however even out out of round necks if needed.
    I dont understand why some handloaders size new brass all they re doing is introducing one extra work hardening cycle, if factory loaded ammunition is acceptable then why not new brass from the same maker?
    All the brass comes off the same line, there are no seperate runs for handloading brass and factory ammo brass they are all the same.

    Ian.

  7. #7
    Join Date
    May 2009
    Location
    Reading
    Posts
    4,806
    Quote Originally Posted by zanes View Post
    Chaps,

    Interesting one here. I've always been told and read that when you're reloading cases that have not been fired in the rifle you're reloading for you must neck size. No qualifications, no "but if they chamber OK you're OK neck sizing only".

    My question is- what am I missing here; the only reason I can think of for full length sizing is to prevent issues with the brass not fitting in the rifle's chamber (for a bolt action for target shooting). I have a quantity of once fired .300 Win Mag brass for my new to me rifle which was not fired in the rifle.

    Happy to full length resize this time if necessary, but prefer neck sizing and trying to work out why I shouldn't.
    I would always full length size once fired brass from another rifle at least the first time, then at least you don't go all the way through the process to find out later that half won't chamber, for example one of my .308's produces cases that won't chamber in the other, same make model and calibre ! not a problem if you full length size, but a buggerence if you have neck sized them! start from a known point and the worlds the mollusc of your choice
    You Cannot Reason People Out of Something They Were Not Reasoned Into
    "Politicians like to panic, they need activity. It is their substitute for achievement" Sir Humphry Appleby

  8. #8
    Join Date
    Jun 2010
    Location
    Manchester
    Posts
    8,331
    The term "resetting" the cartridge case is Form Firing.
    A new case, when you fire it, will stretch to suit the chamber of the rifle. The next time you use it it does not have to stretch and the gas flow will be more consistent which results in better accuracy. After it has been Form Fired all you need to do is neck size.
    The same applies to once fired case from another rifle. If they chamber then form fire them. If they do not chamber FL resize.

    When you fire a cartridge the brass flows forwards, that is why you have to trim them after 3-4 loadings.
    This brass you trim off comes from the base of the cartridge which gets thinner each time you fire the cartridge. Look out for a shiny ring near the base. If you see one scrap the case as it will separate if you continue using it.
    If you want to see what I mean get a piece of plasticine and roll it into a cylinder and then stretch it from either end until it snaps. This is what happens to the brass at the base with continued use.

  9. #9
    Join Date
    Jan 2008
    Location
    Mold (Yr Wyddgrug) N.Wales
    Posts
    18,250
    i have no doubt it would work but its the one that gets stuck "like a good'un" that would put my off the reloading lottery.
    Rapid 7 / 10-22 ATN 2 Stiller Predator .204 Pulsar N970 Tikka T3 semi custom ATN MARS thermal.204 Tikka T3 Semi.223 Wylde IOR Operator Lawton 6mmBR Kahles Gen 3 - Stiller 6.5 x 47 Bushnell BDX - Winchester Red Performance SX3 12g

  10. #10
    Join Date
    Dec 2003
    Location
    Aylesbury
    Posts
    3,412
    Thanks all. Looks like the only sensible option is to try chambering each case and see what the go/no go rate is like.

    As the win mag is fairly hard on brass I don't want to be working it any more than I have to.

  11. #11
    Join Date
    Sep 2014
    Location
    Northampton
    Posts
    3,040

    New cases...

    I have always read that you FLS new cases or once fired cases if you are then going to fire them in another rifle. I bought 300 odd 308 once fired cases and none of them would chamber in my Howa without FLS...after firing, neck sizing was fine. 5 or 6 firings with neck sizing...the bolt becomes a little stiff indicating FLS needed again. I have not had to trim the Lapua cases so far..they seem to be indestructible!

    amc577

  12. #12
    Join Date
    Jun 2010
    Location
    Manchester
    Posts
    8,331
    Quote Originally Posted by amc577 View Post
    I have always read that you FLS new cases or once fired cases if you are then going to fire them in another rifle. I bought 300 odd 308 once fired cases and none of them would chamber in my Howa without FLS...after firing, neck sizing was fine. 5 or 6 firings with neck sizing...the bolt becomes a little stiff indicating FLS needed again. I have not had to trim the Lapua cases so far..they seem to be indestructible!

    amc577
    When you say the bolt becomes a little bit stiff, is this when chambering a round?

    lapua brass is good but it still stretches. When you full length re-size I suspect that you are pushing the shoulder back. The stiffness is most likely to be caused by the neck of the case being too far into the chamber. If you are pushing the shoulder back you alleviate this problem.
    I would try a trimmer and case length gauge on the cases that are tight to chamber.

  13. #13
    Join Date
    Dec 2003
    Location
    Aylesbury
    Posts
    3,412
    Right, as a bit of closure to this.

    My brass boils down into two main categories- a batch of 200 PPU cases I bought off here and about 25 RWS cases I got as range pick up.

    Ran 20 of the PPU through my rifle and they chambered absolutely fine with no resistance once the extractor had hooked on; these will be neck sized, trimmed if needed, rechecked for chambering and then loaded.

    Tried 5 of the RWS and there was resistance to closing that I didn't want to go past; these are going to be full length sized, trimmed and loaded etc. This makes sense to me as I'm 99% sure these were shot from a double rifle which I would expect to have a slacker chamber than most other rifles.

    This seems the most sensible course of action, if nothing else it ensures both of my brand new dies pick up some lube and could be interesting to compare FL to neck sizing in terms of accuracy.
    Last edited by zanes; 05-05-2016 at 08:17 PM.

  14. #14
    Join Date
    May 2008
    Location
    Taunton
    Posts
    815
    Have a read of this excellent article by Kev on ShootForum (he's an ex AGBBS member):

    http://www.shootforum.com/forum/BrassPrep.html

    It certainly makes it less cut and dried and just goes to prove that unless you've tried something yourself then it's hard to take it as gospel...
    Life is short, remember - Carpae Dentum ...

  15. #15
    Join Date
    May 2008
    Location
    Taunton
    Posts
    815
    Quote Originally Posted by zanes View Post
    Chaps,

    Interesting one here. I've always been told and read that when you're reloading cases that have not been fired in the rifle you're reloading for you must neck size. No qualifications, no "but if they chamber OK you're OK neck sizing only".

    My question is- what am I missing here; the only reason I can think of for full length sizing is to prevent issues with the brass not fitting in the rifle's chamber (for a bolt action for target shooting). I have a quantity of once fired .300 Win Mag brass for my new to me rifle which was not fired in the rifle.

    Happy to full length resize this time if necessary, but prefer neck sizing and trying to work out why I shouldn't.

    I just re-read your first post Zanes, is that a typo about only neck sizing? As it should be Full Length Sized if you've got fired brass from another rifle. Sorry if that's been picked up on by another poster already!

    If you're really worried about case life in yer 300WM, it might be worth considering getting the chamber cut to an ackley chamber - a friend of mine did this with his 300 Winmag and gets much improved case life, very low stretch and a good few more FPS too..
    Life is short, remember - Carpae Dentum ...

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •