I agree that the .36 is often unfairly overlooked compared to the 44. We see favourable comparisons on score in our club competitions. Overall, I think the 1858 Pietta Remingtons are excellent value for money and great entry into muzzle loading revolver shooting and indeed will hold their own against far more expensive models. I bought my 1858 44 target model in 1997 new for £150, to enable me to continue with pistol shooting and was immediately impressed with its accuracy. In the 20 years since it is still going strong and has seen numerous competitions ( incl. the odd win and my wife used it to win 3 club championships before getting her own!). More recently I have a Westlake Alfa Prog MLR and this now predominates my use in open (any powder) comps, with the Pietta used in open (due to adjustable sight) but nitro-restricted shoots. I must admit that I have never warmed to the post shoot cleaning regime but I always enjoy shooting it!