I'm a bit late to this one but here's my take. I have 2 x Colt SAA's, a pellet, aged finish, Schofield, a Webley MkVI & a Dan Wesson 715 2.5". My thoughts on them are, Colts, love the click clack when you cock it, the Schofield is as perfect a replica you could wish for, the same also applies to the Webley, it has the best sights of any of them IMO. Lastly the DW, what a little gem of a gun. Probably the best feeling grips I've ever held, great fit & finish. I use mine with the moon clip shells which make loading & unloading so much easier. If I had to pick just one it would be tricky but I'd go with the Schofield.