Andrew

Tony has nailed it on current models. Except the HW35, which should never be bought new (except maybe the funky new nickel one). Get an old walnut E or L.

Honestly, you would be better off buying a classic from 1980-2000ish. Diana 34/36/38 or 45. HW85/35/80/99/50/30. Webley Omega/Tomahawk/Longbow (no iron sights on the last 2). Birmingham BSA Supersport or Mercury S or Challenger. BSF S55, 60 or 70. Annie 335. Etc. Usually cheaper than a new gun, and will hold value.

Nothing has improved in production springers in the last 15 years, and a number of manufacturers (Diana, BSA, HW) appear to have cut corners or shown QC issues, while others (Webley) have folded.