Zeiss HD5 5-25x50, Sightron S3 6-24x50 and S-TAC 2.5-17.5x56 comparison

[Muskett]

This HD5 is on my .17HMR:
http://i820.photobucket.com/albums/z...9/IMG_5160.jpg
http://i820.photobucket.com/albums/z...9/IMG_5153.jpg
This the smaller HD5 3-15x42 and I almost prefer it over the 5-25x50 as it less fussy. Both are 50m parallax start which isn't the end of the world but does mean you can't use max magnification under 50m if you want perfect sharp picture. This parallax also isn't compatible with digi NV add-ons. The HD5 3-15x42 is a cute scope with fantastic optics. Mine has the Zeiss Plex which is what I like because what more do you need when you can dial? Dialing is pretty brilliant even for .17HMR as when you have the time you can make the most of the .17hmr inherent accuracy. Being a small light weight scope it compliments the annie brilliantly. Just love this combination.

I also have the HD5 5-25x50 on my new build .223. I wanted a light weight scope that dialed for my sporting weight rifle. The HD5 certainly meets the bill and the locking turrets are just perfect for the field.

I also have Zeiss Victories. Now these are a whole level up from the HD5's in every category. The HD5's are typical of so many modern scopes in this price bracket. I really rate them, but they do have some limitations; especially when compared to the Victory. They are a bit eye position critical at higher mag. The eye box isn't as forgiving. Its a real must to have them perfectly set up on the right height mounts and correctly matched to your head position/cheek weld. At least the eye relief is fixed unlike some other scopes when you change the magnification. They are also plenty parallax needy at times. The feel of the clicks is a bit light and I use the turret markings. The zoom ring is on the stiffer side (well one is, the other just about perfect). The light gathering is pretty fantastic in daylight and even more so at night or over a white light led torch; but the Victory are a leap better. Nothing above I have not found on similar priced scopes, and its nota criticism. My Bushnell 6500 is close but not as good; and they don't come with those all important locking turrets.

I was zeroing the other day my HMR and Sig 522. The .22 Sig has a Mamba Lite for my NV add-on. Nice bright day to zero. Wow the Mamba was pants in comparison. For tac driving precision zeroing best glass is the biz to get that pin sharp image. Again the Mamba sucked. The HD5 just shone.

Anyhow, I think these HD5 are pretty fantastic all round. For once a feature rich scope that isn't a brick. Just remember to buy them with the locking target turrets.