Page 1 of 3 123 LastLast
Results 1 to 15 of 37

Thread: Measuring Overall Cartridge Length (newbie alert)

  1. #1
    Join Date
    Nov 2010
    Location
    Lancaster
    Posts
    2,248

    Measuring Overall Cartridge Length (newbie alert)

    So, one thing I've learnt so far is that bullets vary in their length quite a bit but there's really two readings to think about:

    1. Cartridge overall length for magazine fit
    2. Ogive measurement for seating depth

    How do you you chaps know the correct seating depths when you're handloading and where do I start? Do I need to buy another specialist bit of kit to measure the ogive in relation to the lands and them work back bit by bit?

    .22LR CZ452; .22 Hornet CZ527
    Tikka T3 Varmint .223; .204 Ruger CZ527 Varmint;
    6.5 Creed Bergara B14 HMR

  2. #2
    Join Date
    Feb 2008
    Location
    Huntingdon
    Posts
    9,253
    Quote Originally Posted by Elliott View Post
    So, one thing I've learnt so far is that bullets vary in their length quite a bit but there's really two readings to think about:

    1. Cartridge overall length for magazine fit
    2. Ogive measurement for seating depth

    How do you you chaps know the correct seating depths when you're handloading and where do I start? Do I need to buy another specialist bit of kit to measure the ogive in relation to the lands and them work back bit by bit?
    Cheap method - uses a fired cartridge case and a bullet that you can use again.

    1. Take your once-fire case and neck size it.

    2. With a fine-blade hacksaw, cut three or four slits in the neck down as far as the shoulder.

    3. Insert the bullet - it should be held fairly tightly by the neck, in spite of the slits, which act as a spring-loaded 'retainer'. Insert it just far enough to be held without falling out.

    4. Use a felt-tipped marker to mark the bullet all round.

    5. Insert the complete item into the breech and close the bolt.

    6. As the bullet touches the rifling, that will push the bullet into the case.

    7. Carefully open the action, and drop the case with the bullet in it gently into your waiting hand.

    8. You now have a dummy cartridge that exactly fits into YOUR breech and 'just' touches the rifling. Exactly WHERE it touches the rifling will be indicated by rifling marks in the felt-tip marking, if you see what I mean.

    9. Using the calipers we told you to buy a couple of months ago, carefully measure the OVERALL LENGTH of the COMPLETE CARTRIDGE. Let us say that it is 2.75"

    10. Whatever that measurement is, begin reloading a series of cartridge, using the same style of bullets, at 0.010" shorter than 2.75". You are now making a finished cartridge that is 0.010" SHORT of the lands of the rifling, for a start, and see how you get on. Some rifles like a bigger 'jump', but remember that being actually in contact with the the rtifling at the moment of ignition meansa that the pressure will peak virtually instantly - having even the slightest 'jump' will reduce that effect by a small amount, possibly resulting in an increase in accuracy. You can increase the amount of shortness by 0.005" at a time until you get the resaults you want. My Krico 650SS likes a 'ten 'thou jump' with Lapua Scenars, but shooting VLD Bergers I have to make allowances as the ogive is so long that the bullet would have nigh-on disappeared up thr barrel by the time it touched the rifling.

    Remember, too, that this will be different of every type of bullet, as has been noted here many times. The longer the ogive, the more the bullet needs to be set out of the case in order to touch the lands - the opposite is therefore true - old-style, short ogive bullets will need careful finagling.

    Expensive method. Buy a Stoney Point cartridge length gauge, or whatever it's called now, for about £50 - 60, that does exactly the same thing, but looks really spiffy.

    You choose.

    tac in Port Orford Oregon, about to go to a HUGE bar-b-q.

  3. #3
    Join Date
    Jan 2013
    Location
    Devizes
    Posts
    5,032
    To start off with I just loaded to book length, with the a-max in my remmy 0.223loaded to saami spec I was shooting very tight groups. Another option that often gets recommended is to use a factory round that the rifle likes and use that to set the seating die, then use that as a starting point. Obviously the ogive is going to vary from one bullet type to another but if its a point to start from.

    Is mag length particularly restrictive on your Tikka? As its a 1:12 you're not going to be loading heavy long bullets so i can't imagine you're going to have an issue, until you buy a hornet at least!!
    Thanks for looking

  4. #4
    Join Date
    Jun 2005
    Location
    Marlow, Bucks
    Posts
    7,060
    Quote Originally Posted by tacfoley View Post
    Cheap method - uses a fired cartridge case and a bullet that you can use again.

    1. Take your once-fire case and neck size it.

    2. With a fine-blade hacksaw, cut three or four slits in the neck down as far as the shoulder.

    etc
    etc

    Expensive method. Buy a Stoney Point cartridge length gauge, or whatever it's called now, for about £50 - 60, that does exactly the same thing, but looks really spiffy.

    You choose.

    tac in Port Orford Oregon, about to go to a HUGE bar-b-q.

    Very useful. Thanks.

  5. #5
    Join Date
    Jan 2008
    Location
    Mold (Yr Wyddgrug) N.Wales
    Posts
    18,250
    you can do it with a cleaning rod too........

    1. insert as above with bullet inserted so its T I G H T (not primed obvs) and slowly close bolt .....make a mark on rod where its position is with end of barrel.

    2. take cartridge out and close bolt. Reinsert rod and make a mark on cleaning road again.

    3. measure......


    also you may see that BT bullets vary (tips not the same length) quite a lot with measuring COL so the i measure to the ogive now using a stoney point gauge.
    Rapid 7 / 10-22 ATN 2 Stiller Predator .204 Pulsar N970 Tikka T3 semi custom ATN MARS thermal.204 Tikka T3 Semi.223 Wylde IOR Operator Lawton 6mmBR Kahles Gen 3 - Stiller 6.5 x 47 Bushnell BDX - Winchester Red Performance SX3 12g

  6. #6
    Join Date
    Sep 2010
    Location
    edinburgh
    Posts
    1,571
    or......

    ignore this fascination with loading a "gnat's chuff off the lands"...

    load all rounds "at least a calibre depth" so that they are under book maximum OAL

    fine tune the best charge level groups either side of the length to get the best groups

    most rifles will produce just as accurate rounds with some "jump" as they will almost touching the lands


    I load for .22hornet, .222, .243, .270, .308 and .300WM......couldn't tell you where the lands are on any of them!
    FWIW the .308 I just sold shot in the 0.1-0.2MOA range

  7. #7
    Join Date
    Jan 2013
    Location
    Devizes
    Posts
    5,032
    Quote Originally Posted by bewsh View Post
    or......

    ignore this fascination with loading a "gnat's chuff off the lands"...

    load all rounds "at least a calibre depth" so that they are under book maximum OAL

    fine tune the best charge level groups either side of the length to get the best groups

    most rifles will produce just as accurate rounds with some "jump" as they will almost touching the lands


    I load for .22hornet, .222, .243, .270, .308 and .300WM......couldn't tell you where the lands are on any of them!
    FWIW the .308 I just sold shot in the 0.1-0.2MOA range
    Funnily enough Ed the load data for the 168 gr SMK that you gave me for that very 0.308 at "40 thou off the dummy round" worked on near as damn it book length for .308!!

    Taking her out to 1000 yards with the BBS boys Sunday, I'll let you know how I get on!!

    As KennyC said to me recently the touble with loading to the lands is the lands are always moving away from you!!
    Thanks for looking

  8. #8
    Join Date
    Jan 2008
    Location
    Daventry. Northants.
    Posts
    3,534
    The first thing we need to establish is are you going to feed from the magazine or load singularly?
    Super accurate base to ogive measurement really only comes into its own when you require a precise bullet jam length, in other words the distance from the bullet to the rifling.

    This is usually the domain of those looking for absolutely accuracy, who load rounds singularly and are looking for an exact amount of engagement into or awy from the rifling.
    If you are feeding from the magazine then you only need to concern yourself with the COAL, making sure all cartridges are the same length from the base to the tip, espacially if you are seating to the max length that will load into the magazine.

    However the trade off here is that due to varying bullet lengths the cartridge base to bullet ogive measurement may be different for each round in the mag, detrimental to ultimate accuracy.
    The best way in my opinion is to seat bullets to a working depth for feeding out of the magazine with the critical dimension being that of the base to the ogive, for this you will need to get yourself a bullet comparator

    TB.

  9. #9
    Join Date
    Nov 2010
    Location
    Lancaster
    Posts
    2,248
    Thanks, some good advice there!

    Quote Originally Posted by Treebone View Post
    The first thing we need to establish is are you going to feed from the magazine or load singularly?
    Super accurate base to ogive measurement really only comes into its own when you require a precise bullet jam length, in other words the distance from the bullet to the rifling.

    This is usually the domain of those looking for absolutely accuracy, who load rounds singularly and are looking for an exact amount of engagement into or awy from the rifling.
    If you are feeding from the magazine then you only need to concern yourself with the COAL, making sure all cartridges are the same length from the base to the tip, espacially if you are seating to the max length that will load into the magazine.

    However the trade off here is that due to varying bullet lengths the cartridge base to bullet ogive measurement may be different for each round in the mag, detrimental to ultimate accuracy.
    The best way in my opinion is to seat bullets to a working depth for feeding out of the magazine with the critical dimension being that of the base to the ogive, for this you will need to get yourself a bullet comparator

    TB.
    The rounds will be magazine fed through my Tikka. Looks like it may be best to invest in a bullet comparator

    .22LR CZ452; .22 Hornet CZ527
    Tikka T3 Varmint .223; .204 Ruger CZ527 Varmint;
    6.5 Creed Bergara B14 HMR

  10. #10
    Join Date
    Nov 2009
    Location
    preston
    Posts
    3,711
    Quote Originally Posted by bewsh View Post
    or......

    ignore this fascination with loading a "gnat's chuff off the lands"...

    load all rounds "at least a calibre depth" so that they are under book maximum OAL

    fine tune the best charge level groups either side of the length to get the best groups

    most rifles will produce just as accurate rounds with some "jump" as they will almost touching the lands


    I load for .22hornet, .222, .243, .270, .308 and .300WM......couldn't tell you where the lands are on any of them!
    FWIW the .308 I just sold shot in the 0.1-0.2MOA range







    Good advice there, i recently did a load for my and a mates .243s using some hollow point bullets i couldn't find a figure for. On the advice of someone who reloads a lot i set the bullets into the case's 6mm deep and tried them. They are deadly accurate in both rifles, my mate neck shot a Roe buck at 360yds with his no problem at all.

  11. #11
    Join Date
    Jan 2013
    Location
    Devizes
    Posts
    5,032
    Quote Originally Posted by jackal1 View Post
    They are deadly accurate in both rifles, my mate neck shot a Roe buck at 360yds with his no problem at all.
    Thanks for looking

  12. #12
    Join Date
    May 2009
    Location
    Reading
    Posts
    4,806
    Quote Originally Posted by Boydy47 View Post
    He was probably aiming for a H/L shot
    Or is a dick
    You Cannot Reason People Out of Something They Were Not Reasoned Into
    "Politicians like to panic, they need activity. It is their substitute for achievement" Sir Humphry Appleby

  13. #13
    Join Date
    Nov 2009
    Location
    preston
    Posts
    3,711
    Quote Originally Posted by kennyc View Post
    He was probably aiming for a H/L shot
    Or is a dick
    Don't judge everyone by your own standards.

  14. #14
    Join Date
    Jan 2013
    Location
    Devizes
    Posts
    5,032
    Quote Originally Posted by jackal1 View Post
    Don't judge everyone by your own standards.
    I wouldn't go posting about the shot on the stalking directory that's for sure!!

    To be fair I'd be happy with Kenny's standard, I've seen him consistently hit the bull at 900 yards with Irons, I struggled with a scope!
    Thanks for looking

  15. #15
    Join Date
    May 2009
    Location
    Reading
    Posts
    4,806
    Quote Originally Posted by jackal1 View Post
    Don't judge everyone by your own standards.
    I don't, thats why I gave the option he was a Dick ! anyone should be able to hit a small target at that distance as long as that target doesn't move! I can't think of many circumstances when a neck shot at that distance would be a suitable choice, a deers spine is curved and not in the centre of its neck, it is attached to its head, which seems to me to spend a lot of time moving and twitching, taking the neck along for the ride ! add in wind and you have a possibility of disaster.
    I can quite understand a H/L shot going high into a high shoulder shot which in effect is a neck shot, but once you have had to go and finish off a deer in that condition (paralysed and desperately trying to get up and run) then you may lose your taste for those "expert shots"
    besides you miss the point, if you want to prove accuracy of a round then a paper target is the only way, you can then see the results and duplicate them with as few variables as possible.
    You Cannot Reason People Out of Something They Were Not Reasoned Into
    "Politicians like to panic, they need activity. It is their substitute for achievement" Sir Humphry Appleby

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •