ASG Dan Wesson 715?

[ejackyou]

Why choose BB instead of Pellet?

[mrto]

The bb version of guns like this typically have higher fps and are more fun,( to me) peppering steel cans with.They are usually no more accurate in pellet form either,though the 715 may be an exception to this 'rule'..

[gingernut]

Why choose BB instead of Pellet?

I didn't.
Got both

[mrto]

I didn't.
Got both

Which do you prefer?

[gingernut]

Pellet is easier to load (no need to remove shells) and a great colour/finish.
Pretty good at 20 yard tins which I didn't expect.

I haven't sorted the bb one yet but I suspect it won't be as good.
£20 cheaper.
Will let you know after weekend.
Weather permitting!

[gingernut]

Bb version at the range yesterday.
Using Umarex BBs.
No chrono but power seems good even on chilly day.

I only shot at cans 6 10 and 20 yards.
Accuracy better than your average BB gun although double action needs to wear in.
It pulls the gun offline as did the pellet versions but that is getting slicker.
Noisy gun and makes good impact noise.
Heavy!

But here (as the Americans say) is the thing.

I had a Peacemaker with me by accident ( as you do!) and it comprehensively outshot the 715.
We are talking hitting nearly all cans at all ranges,knocking them off the table at 10m and BBs penetrating and whizzing round inside the can.
Not so the 715.

Annoyingly the Peacemaker is quiet -which is a design fault in my view!

The 715 may be better in warmer weather but I have to say I now know why I have more than one Peacemaker.

The bb 715 is not as accurate as the pellet version and is better than the old DWs and my 4inch Colt Python ,but Umarex have done a fine job on the Peacemaker which is a hard act to follow.

[mrto]

Interesting,thanks for the update!

If I get a 715 then it will be the pellet firing version, I think.It was a very useful comparison for me as the owner of three Colt SAA's to hear how the 715 stacks up against them in bb format.

Hopefully Umarex will bring the Colt out in the 7 1/2" cavalry barrel length,though the revolver will be even quieter then I would imagine,but as long as the valve is unchanged it should produce higher fps which would be great.

Fingers crossed!

ATB.

[ejackyou]

Bb version at the range yesterday.
Using Umarex BBs.
No chrono but power seems good even on chilly day.

I only shot at cans 6 10 and 20 yards.
Accuracy better than your average BB gun although double action needs to wear in.
It pulls the gun offline as did the pellet versions but that is getting slicker.
Noisy gun and makes good impact noise.
Heavy!

But here (as the Americans say) is the thing.

I had a Peacemaker with me by accident ( as you do!) and it comprehensively outshot the 715.
We are talking hitting nearly all cans at all ranges,knocking them off the table at 10m and BBs penetrating and whizzing round inside the can.
Not so the 715.

Annoyingly the Peacemaker is quiet -which is a design fault in my view!

The 715 may be better in warmer weather but I have to say I now know why I have more than one Peacemaker.

The bb 715 is not as accurate as the pellet version and is better than the old DWs and my 4inch Colt Python ,but Umarex have done a fine job on the Peacemaker which is a hard act to follow.

Thanks for the insight, will be interesting to see how the Pellet versions of the two guns compare?

[gingernut]

Stop trying to make me buy more pistols!

They have the pellet Webley in our local shop and they keep tempting me with it .
But £200 is too much to spend on a comparison.

Strangely they wont lend me one.