Results 1 to 15 of 15

Thread: Why do top Olympic air pistol shooters only use Steyr, Morini or Walther?

Hybrid View

Previous Post Previous Post   Next Post Next Post
  1. #1
    Join Date
    Aug 2007
    Location
    Stafford
    Posts
    4,836
    Yes, the vast bias in the medal tables at major internationals shows it is not just club shooters getting shiny kit syndrome.

    Someone will doubtless shoot me down in flames, but as I see it, there is less room or need for variation in pistol than rifle for instance.

    With a rifle, you've got to consider weight, butt length, foreend length and depth, different sight options, cheekpiece options, pistol grip adjustment, trigger, etc, etc. Some people do 3P, some are prone specialists. There's a need for a lot of different stock designs and configurations. You find the stock that fits you and your disciplines, and then get a good barrel and action to fit it.

    With pistol, it's at arm's length. For a right-handed shooter, the left arm is irrelevant, unlike in rifle where it's very relevant. Whereas rifle has the list of above considerations, with pistol you're worried about:
    - Accuracy
    - Trigger
    - Weight
    - Grip

    Now the manufacturer can control the first 3 of those, and realistically the grip ends up being a bespoke home-custom job with modelling putty. You simply don't need so much factory-made variation in design to accommodate different people.

    Steyr, Morini, Walther and Pardini have got a reputation for getting the first two absolutely right, and offer their pistols in a variety of weights, so finding one that fits the shooter is not an issue.

    Without wishing to cast aspersions on the other guns (Anschutz make a great gun - their rifles are world beaters, as do FWB and the others), you're paying for the knowledge that these guns are time-proven Olympic champions if you do your bit. You also know their service teams will be at every major match. Do Benelli and FAS send service teams to all the World Cups, etc? (I don't actually know... do they? I would imagine Steyr get to more pistol matches than Benelli, so we're talking about substantial after-sales support).
    When you've spent 4 years of your life dedicated to training, you want to know that:
    (1) Your gun isn't going to break halfway through the Olympic final
    (2) If it does, there is an engineer from the manufacturer stood 10 yards away at the back of the range

    Also, if your Steyr breaks, the guy next door to you, and the one next to him probably have the same gun, and the RO probably shoots one when he's not officiating! Why go with something less common when the popular and well-supported one works so well. You just pick the model that's weighted right for you, customise the grip and crack on.

    It not a case that the uncommon ones are inaccurate or unreliable, it's just if you're competing at an international level, the difference between £300 and £800 as a long-term investment is not that great. You need the right tool for the job. You can look at a Steyr and go "That works brilliantly. I've seen it work brilliantly. I know it will continue to work brilliantly."

    And yeah, sponsorship plays a part as well
    "A fear of weapons is a sign of retarded sexual and emotional maturity." Sigmund Freud
    Shooting is my meditation

  2. #2
    Join Date
    May 2006
    Location
    Birmingham
    Posts
    3,642
    Hemmers is right in what he says. Top shooters are always going to have worked through the options and picked what is best for them. Sales support is clearly important and so is sponsorship, I suppose. But 90% of shooting success (probably more) will always be down to the shooter not the gun. I still see FWB300 and Walther LGR rifles at regional comps (and the Eley-NSRA final at Bisley). I have been in the Eley Bisley finals and finished in the top quartile of my regional competitions using an FWB65. The nut behind the trigger is always the part that counts.

  3. #3
    tufty is offline I wondered how that worked..
    Join Date
    Nov 2009
    Location
    claygate
    Posts
    2,370
    Its really down to the fit of the pistol, nearly all of those pistols will shoot hole on hole benchclamped. I have 2 steyr's an lp10 and an lp50, and both have test cards are like this, though the lp50 is a bit more ragged
    the great advantage of these is the almost infinate level of adjustability, even in the electronic trigger version, this is what makes the difference at the top level of shooting(which I am nowhere near)
    Steyr LG110 Hunter,AA410 in Gary Cane stock,HC, Steyr LP50,Morini 164ei,Morini CM84e,Anschutz 1417 thumbhole,Rimfire Magic 10/22,Anschutz 1913,Rieder and Lenz Z2,Keppeler 6mmbr

  4. #4
    Jim McArthur is offline Frock coat wearing, riverboat dwelling, southern gent
    Join Date
    Sep 2007
    Location
    New Orleans, Louisiana
    Posts
    5,887
    Quote Originally Posted by Hemmers View Post
    Yes, the vast bias in the medal tables at major internationals shows it is not just club shooters getting shiny kit syndrome.

    Someone will doubtless shoot me down in flames, but as I see it, there is less room or need for variation in pistol than rifle for instance.

    With a rifle, you've got to consider weight, butt length, foreend length and depth, different sight options, cheekpiece options, pistol grip adjustment, trigger, etc, etc. Some people do 3P, some are prone specialists. There's a need for a lot of different stock designs and configurations. You find the stock that fits you and your disciplines, and then get a good barrel and action to fit it.

    With pistol, it's at arm's length. For a right-handed shooter, the left arm is irrelevant, unlike in rifle where it's very relevant. Whereas rifle has the list of above considerations, with pistol you're worried about:
    - Accuracy
    - Trigger
    - Weight
    - Grip

    Now the manufacturer can control the first 3 of those, and realistically the grip ends up being a bespoke home-custom job with modelling putty. You simply don't need so much factory-made variation in design to accommodate different people.

    Steyr, Morini, Walther and Pardini have got a reputation for getting the first two absolutely right, and offer their pistols in a variety of weights, so finding one that fits the shooter is not an issue.

    Without wishing to cast aspersions on the other guns (Anschutz make a great gun - their rifles are world beaters, as do FWB and the others), you're paying for the knowledge that these guns are time-proven Olympic champions if you do your bit. You also know their service teams will be at every major match. Do Benelli and FAS send service teams to all the World Cups, etc? (I don't actually know... do they? I would imagine Steyr get to more pistol matches than Benelli, so we're talking about substantial after-sales support).
    When you've spent 4 years of your life dedicated to training, you want to know that:
    (1) Your gun isn't going to break halfway through the Olympic final
    (2) If it does, there is an engineer from the manufacturer stood 10 yards away at the back of the range

    Also, if your Steyr breaks, the guy next door to you, and the one next to him probably have the same gun, and the RO probably shoots one when he's not officiating! Why go with something less common when the popular and well-supported one works so well. You just pick the model that's weighted right for you, customise the grip and crack on.

    It not a case that the uncommon ones are inaccurate or unreliable, it's just if you're competing at an international level, the difference between £300 and £800 as a long-term investment is not that great. You need the right tool for the job. You can look at a Steyr and go "That works brilliantly. I've seen it work brilliantly. I know it will continue to work brilliantly."

    And yeah, sponsorship plays a part as well
    WHEW! All that makes me realize that I'll always be just a plinker: and always happy to be just a plinker!

    Jim
    UBC's Police Pistol Manager
    "Nasty, noisy things, revolvers, Count. Better stick to air-guns." Sherlock Holmes, The Adventure of the Mazarin Stone

  5. #5
    Join Date
    Jul 2010
    Location
    bristol
    Posts
    10
    You know it's funny that these fancy guns boil down to fit, because most of us never get a chance to really test them all out. They're just to rare and expensive to get a crack at! Though I guess this goes towards the argument of infinite adjustability. Make a gun that will shoot straight and can be made to fit anyone perfectly and your set. Right? Though I do really appreciate the argument of having a gun that you'll likely have good support for, and you will see other people shoot as well, in case something does go wrong with your gun during a match. Good points.

  6. #6
    Join Date
    Aug 2007
    Location
    Stafford
    Posts
    4,836
    Yeah, this is the issue with rifles. there are so many stocks available that it's difficult to get a go with all of them. To list a few:
    Couple of different Anschutz Wood stocks
    Anschutz Alu-stock
    Anschutz "Precise" Alu-Stock
    2x Feinwerkbau Alu-stocks
    Walther Alu-stock
    HPS Gemini
    Bleiker
    Evolution 600
    MEC Project
    Grunig and Elmiger

    With a plethora of different barrels, actions, bloop tubes, etc, etc available to change the weight, balance and feel of each stock!

    With AP, get a go with a Steyr, a Walther and a Morini and you'll have a pretty good idea of what works for you.


    With an air pistol, you're customising the one point of contact (grip) anyway and tweaking the trigger, so it's really just a matter of picking one that weighs the right amount, fettling it and learning to shoot straight.

    By comparison with rifle you have 5 points of contact - sling; left hand; right hand; shoulder; cheek.
    Much more to take into consideration when selecting the stock, and then much more to get set up and replicate for each shoot.
    Last edited by Hemmers; 05-07-2010 at 10:18 PM.
    "A fear of weapons is a sign of retarded sexual and emotional maturity." Sigmund Freud
    Shooting is my meditation

  7. #7
    Join Date
    Jul 2007
    Location
    Great Yarmouth Norfolk
    Posts
    1,691
    Hemmers, when it comes to rifle stocks you forgot the new Keppler. It's very good, a friend has one, it is really working well for him. Think there's 4 or 5 wood Anschutz stocks, but that dose include the BR one as well.


    Alan

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •