What's the best replica, Co2, non blowback, BB pistol?

[Jaythebass]

You can’t go wrong with either the CP88 or the M92FS. Both are solid

[Meggadeath]

Each of the Umarex Replicas using the eight-count rotary magazine uses the exact same valve (CP88, Beretta, Colt 1911, etc). They all are relatively "miserly" with CO2.

[gwyn]

Have you considered the Webley Nemisis pistol,modern looking and an excellent trigger also cheap cost wise!
Don.

[Nigeld]

How about a Webley mk vi. Looks and feels like the real thing. Available in different barrel lengths and finishes.

[GridNorth]

There is no easy answer. I have inadvertently become a collector. I have an HW40, a Dan Wesson pellet, an Umarex Berretta 92fs pellet and a Remington 1911 BB. The latter is the least accurate because it has blowback and is BB but it also the one I take out of it's case the most often. The HW40 is by far the most accurate but is not really a replica. The Dan Wesson and Beretta are about the same accuracy wise but the Berretta is the least fun to shoot of them all. So much so that I am considering selling it and starting a more realistic replica collection. My issue with the Berretta is that if you tilt the gun ever so slightly before closing the slide the magazine drops out and the pellets end up all over the floor. It's as much me as the gun but it still annoys me.

Al

[Tony.T]

Just to add a different slant- a few weeks back I bought a Walther PPQ pellet bowback.

The reviews I read where very good and when I saw one come up for sale S/H I jumped on it.

I have to say it's excellent. Weighty, well made (by Walther for Umarex) and looks very good indeed. But get this- compared to my other CO2 pistols (apart from my Alfa Project 10m pistol) it's very accurate- more so than all of my other co2 pistols, pellet or BB including non-blowback. The blowback is crisp and the pistol barks nicely. I get around 60 shots out of one capsule easily.
Highly recommended.