Silencers, Moderators, Suppressors for PCP's ???

[angrybear]

Well I use the classic HW on a couple, A&M Twink on my FAC .25 (might be about to change) & a modified standard shroud on my MFR.

Thoughts/opinions,
there are many mods that work to a greater or lesser extent, there are a few that are useless,
generally I don't find that rimfire mods work particularly well on sub 12, although the A-tec wave is meant for rimfire, so maybe those do.

Phutt for your buck, the HW is probably still the benchmark.

[zephyr]

Daystate Mk4is - none, super accurate, so I don't want to do anything to change that
AA S400 - AA silencer, not exactly hearing damaging with or without
HW110 - HW silencer, hammer noise is loudest
Daystate Pulsar - shrouded barrel (had a Hugget, but unnecessary)
BSA Ultra - HW silencer, works well and on the cusp of being a benefit
HW30 - none, doesn't need any

Plus 'beauty is in the eyes of the beholder' and to my eyes they detract from the lines of the barrel

[gsxrman]

Only have a mod on my Rapid, and its a custom one off, had it years.
Didn't rate the Evo even with Vortex sticky on bit.

[PLAGUE]

Phutt for your buck, the HW is probably still the benchmark.

As AB says.

[Craig-P]

How do the new HW XL moderators stack up against the older versions?

[Bellycrawler]

AWT on my FaC air & modified HW body fitted with modified Logun QGS internals on my sub 12's. A few years ago I compared different mods on several rifles both .177 & .22 but things have much changed since then. I'm happy with what I have but verry tempted to try an A Tec Wave

[angrybear]

How do the new HW XL moderators stack up against the older versions?

I'm yet to see a positive comment if ever there was a case of "if it ain't broke..." HW mods are it.

[popgunfan]

How do the new HW XL moderators stack up against the older versions?

I personally having tried both think they are bl00dy awful, no where near as good as the older, CHEAPER standard one in fact the good old £45.00 SAK mod is far better IMHO !!

[Craig-P]

I'm yet to see a positive comment if ever there was a case of "if it ain't broke..." HW mods are it.

I personally having tried both think they are bl00dy awful, no where near as good as the older, CHEAPER standard one in fact the good old £45.00 SAK mod is far better IMHO !!

I've no experience with them but this is the same opinion that I heard from the guy I was chatting with. Apparently they're also a far bit dearer than the 'MK1' HW version.
It would seem the extra cost has gone into creating the new appearance and not improving the performance...

[bootneckbob]

Weihrauch XLK short for my 9015 and Steyr Challenge for garden practice. Steyr just needed a spacer to keep the silencer off the quick fill. Shoot them both without elsewhere because I like the shortness of both rifles.